成都平原饮用水中典型酚类内分泌干扰物分布特征及暴露评估

    Distribution characteristics and exposure assessment of typical phenol endocrine-disrupting chemicals in drinking water in Chengdu plain, China

    • 摘要:
      目的 了解成都平原饮用水中酚类内分泌干扰物(phenol endocrine-disrupting chemicals,PEDCs)浓度水平,并进行暴露评估。
      方法 于2023年7—11月选取成都平原6城市24家市政供水水厂进行水源水、出厂水和末梢水水样(每个水厂各采集1份)采集,采用固相萃取和超高效液相色谱串联质谱法检测11种PEDCs浓度;根据中国人群暴露参数手册中的饮用水污染物暴露评估方法,对饮用水中残留的PEDCs进行暴露评估,采用雌激素活性相关风险模型评价饮用水中PEDCs对人体的健康风险。
      结果 成都平原饮用水中11种PEDCs均有检出,总浓度M(P25, P75)为177(49,575)ng/L;检出率大于40%的有3种,分别为壬基酚、双酚AF和辛基酚;烷基酚类总浓度大于双酚类,差异有统计学意义(Z=-9.15,P < 0.001)。6城市检出率和检出浓度最高的均是壬基酚,且B、E和F市检出浓度较高;F市检出率大于40%的PEDCs种类最多,B市最少,6城市PEDCs总浓度、烷基酚类浓度和双酚类浓度差异有统计学意义(χ2分别为13.74、13.99和15.82,P < 0.05)。水源水PEDCs总浓度M(P25P75)为538(241,1 329)ng/L;出厂水PEDCs总浓度M(P25P75)为105(38,388)ng/L;末梢水PEDCs总浓度M(P25P75)为79 (40,166)ng/L。不同水源类型烷基酚类、双酚类和PEDCs总浓度差异有统计学意义(χ2为20.60~21.64,P < 0.05)。两两比较结果显示,水源水中的烷基酚类、双酚类和PEDCs总浓度分别高于出厂水和末梢水,差异有统计学意义(校正后的P < 0.05)。暴露评估分析显示,不同年龄和性别组的PEDCs日均暴露剂量范围为0.02~4.90 ng/(kg ·d),最大暴露剂量范围为0.16~68.88 ng/(kg ·d)。其中,0~ < 3个月的女孩,总PEDCs、烷基酚类和双酚类最大日均暴露量分别为68.88、68.85和0.40 ng/(kg ·d),为各年龄段和性别中最高。末梢水中6种PEDCs的雌激素毒性当量值均远小于1 ng E2/L。
      结论 成都平原6城市饮用水中均检出痕量PEDCs,浓度水平在ng/L,不同年龄和性别组通过饮用水暴露双酚类内分泌干扰物量远低于欧洲食品安全局推荐的阈值4 μg/(kg ·d),相对安全;同时无雌激素活性健康风险。但应进一步加强对生活饮用水卫生标准外高检出率、高检出浓度的壬基酚、辛基酚和双酚AF的关注。

       

      Abstract:
      Objective To determine the concentrations of phenol endocrine-disrupting chemicals (PEDCs) in drinking water in Chengdu plain, China and to conduct an exposure assessment.
      Methods A total of 24 municipal water supply plants from six cities in Chengdu plain were selected for collection of source water, finished water, and terminal water samples (each one sample in everyone plant) from July to November 2023. Solid-phase extraction and ultra-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry were used to determine the concentrations of 11 PEDCs. The exposure assessment of residual PEDCs in drinking water was conducted according to the method for exposure assessment of pollutants in drinking water in the Exposure Factors Handbook of Chinese Population. The health risks of PEDCs in drinking water to humans were evaluated using an estrogenic activity-associated risk model.
      Results Eleven PEDCs were detected in drinking water in Chengdu plain, with a median total concentration (P25, P75) of 177 (49, 575) ng/L. There were three PEDCs with detection rates greater than 40%, including nonylphenol, bisphenol AF, and octylphenol. The total concentration of alkylphenols was significantly higher than that of bisphenols (Z=-9.15, P < 0.001). The highest detection rate and concentration were observed in nonylphenol in six cities, with the higher detection concentration in B, E, and F cities. The types of PEDCs with detection rates greater than 40% were the most in F city and the fewest in B city. There was a significant difference in the total concentration of PEDCs, the concentration of alkylphenols and the concentration of bisphenols among six cities (χ2=13.74, 13.99 and 15.82, P < 0.05). The median total concentration (P25, P75) of PEDCs was 538 (241, 1 329) ng/L in source water, 105 (38, 388) ng/L in finished water, and 79 (40, 166) ng/L in terminal water. There was a significant difference in the total concentration of alkylphenols, bisphenols, and PEDCs among different types of water sources (χ2=20.60-21.64, P < 0.05). The pairwise comparison results showed that the total concentrations of alkylphenols, bisphenols, and PEDCs in source water were significantly higher than those in finished water and terminal water, respectively (corrected P < 0.05). The exposure assessment analysis showed that the average daily exposure dose of PEDCs in different age and gender groups was 0.02-4.90 ng/(kg ·d), and the maximum exposure dose was 0.16-68.88 ng/(kg ·d). Girls aged 0- < 3 months had the highest average daily exposure dose for total PEDCs, alkylphenols, and bisphenols among all age and sex groups, which were 68.88, 68.85, and 0.40 ng/(kg ·d), respectively. The estrogenic activity-associated risk analysis of PEDCs showed that the estrogenic toxicity equivalent values of six PEDCs in terminal water were all much lower than 1 ng E2/L, indicating no risk to health.
      Conclusion Trace amounts of PEDCs, at the concentration in ng/L, are detected in the drinking water of six cities in Chengdu plain. The exposure of bisphenols to drinking water by different age and sex groups is much lower than the threshold of 4 μg/(kg ·d) recommended by the European Food Safety Authority and relatively safe. At the same time, there is no estrogenic activity-associated health risk. However, further attention should be paid to nonylphenol, octylphenol, and bisphenol AF, which have high detection rates and concentrations outside the standards for drinking water quality.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回